Rivet vs Screw - Difference Between Rivet and Screw
Rivmate Fastener
Top Rivet and Rivet Nut Manufacturer in China
Table of Contents
In fields such as mechanical structures, sheet metal processing, equipment housings, and transportation manufacturing, the choice between rivets vs screws is a common technical point of contention in structural design and assembly selection. Rivets, with their non-removable nature and high vibration resistance, are widely used in aviation, automotive, and lightweight structures. Screws, on the other hand, are extensively used in equipment maintenance, electronic housings, and industrial assembly scenarios due to their reusable and flexible adaptability.
Many engineers encounter the following questions in practical applications: Are rivets stronger than screws? Can they be interchanged? In which scenarios should rivets be prioritized over screws? This article will delve into the core differences between the two from multiple dimensions, including structural performance, installation processes, waterproofing, and disassembly capabilities.
Table of Contents
What is a Pop Rivet?
Pop rivet is a commonly used fastener for mechanical fixing connections. It is also known as a blind rivet, pop rivet or pull rivet.
A pop rivet can be made from a variety of materials, including aluminum, steel or stainless steel. Of course, if you have special material customization needs, you can also find pop rivet manufacturer to customize special material for you. Of course, there is usually a minimum order requirement.
Why Pop rivets are so popular is because they have many advantages. It can solve many problems that other fasteners can’t. These include quick installation, no reverse access, suitability for a wide range of materials and shapes of workpieces, reliable fastening performance, and lower cost. It is widely used in many industries and applications, especially in automotive, aerospace, construction and electronics manufacturing.
What is a Screw?
A screw is a helical threaded fastener that can be tightened or loosened by torque on the head.
Screws come in a variety of sizes, lengths, and types, each used for a specific application. Common types of screws include wood screws, machine screws, self-tapping screws, sheetrock screws, and concrete screws. Screws can be made from different materials such as steel, stainless steel, brass or aluminum, depending on the desired strength, corrosion resistance and application requirements.
Screws are widely used in construction, woodworking, furniture assembly, electronics, automotive and many other industries. They provide a versatile and efficient method of joining materials together, providing strong and reliable connections that can be easily assembled and disassembled with the right tools.
What is the Difference Between Rivet and Screw?
| Feature/Criteria | Rivets | Screws |
|---|---|---|
| Connection Type | Permanent, Non-threaded | Removable, Threaded |
| Installation Access | Often single-side (Blind Rivet) | Requires dual access or torque |
| Shear Strength | High (esp. structural rivets) | Moderate to high (depends on type) |
| Tensile Strength | Moderate | High (especially with bolts) |
| Waterproof Potential | High (sealed rivets) | Lower, needs gasket/sealant |
| Vibration Resistance | Excellent | May loosen without lock mechanism |
| Reusability | No | Yes |
| Tool Requirement | Rivet gun or squeezer | Screwdriver, torque wrench |
Rivet vs Screw: Differences in connection methods
- Rivets form permanent, non-removable connections through deformation of their own material or expansion of the core rod, and are typically used in structures that are no longer disassembled after product molding.
- Screws rely on threads to screw into materials or nuts to form removable clamping connections, and are suitable for structural parts that require long maintenance cycles and multiple assembly and disassembly operations.
Rivet vs Screw: Strength Performance
- Rivets have excellent shear strength and vibration resistance, and perform more stably in high-speed motion, cyclic loads, or high fatigue environments.
- Screws have higher axial clamping force and tensile strength, and are more advantageous in nut assemblies or multi-layer structures, but their vibration resistance depends on additional anti-loosening measures.
Rivet vs Screw: Installation method and accessibility
- Rivets are commonly used in blind side structures and are fixed by drawing or pressing, resulting in high installation efficiency.
- Screws typically require space on both sides (or pre-embedded nuts) and precise torque control during installation, making them suitable for maintenance scenarios.
Rivet vs Screw: Waterproofing and sealing capabilities
- Rivets can be selected with a closed structure or a design with a sealing gasket, enabling a high level of waterproofing without the need for additional sealant.
- Screw connections are prone to micro-gaps and require gaskets, sealant, or O-rings for auxiliary sealing. Long-term water resistance is significantly affected by the environment.
Rivet vs Screw: Dismantling and maintenance adaptability
- Once installed, rivets cannot be reused and must be removed using destructive methods, making them suitable for one-time molding structures.
- Screws support multiple assembly and replacement cycles and are more suitable for system connection parts that require maintenance, upgrades, and debugging.
Are Screws Better than Rivets?
When asked whether rivets or screws work better, you can refer to the following. Our engineers at Rivmate Fastener have summarized the following points, which we hope you will find helpful.
Before reading the following, I hope you can understand the saying “There is no such thing as the best fastener, there is only the most suitable fastener.”
- In the vast majority of industrial use scenarios, rivets are considered easier to use and more practical than screws. Rivets generally provide a stronger and more secure connection. They spread the load over a larger area and are suitable for applications that require high strength and structural integrity.
- In contrast to screws, rivets make a permanent connection. They are not reusable. Screws have the advantage of being easily removable and reusable. They can be easily disassembled and reassembled several times for situations that require frequent adjustments, maintenance or disassembly.
- Rivets are quicker and easier to install than screws. Rivets can be installed quickly with the help of specialized tools. However, rivets require holes to be drilled in advance, whereas screws can be installed directly into the wood.
- While rivets are typically used to join sheet metal, screws can be used on a wider range of materials, including wood, plastic and metal.
So the choice of screws or rivets depends on the requirements of the specific application, including required strength, disassembly needs, installation constraints, material compatibility and aesthetic considerations. You need to evaluate these factors and choose the attachment method that best suits your project.
If your project requires a strong and stable joint, and the material of the joint is metal, I suggest you choose rivets for your project. If you need to join wood, such as furniture, you can use screws to complete the process.
What is Stronger, Pop Rivets or Screws?
With the above description, you can clearly know that rivets are stronger than screws! Rivets provide a stronger and more secure connection, and its unique design of spreading the load enhances shear strength and load carrying capacity.
In contrast, screws maintain a connection through friction with the surrounding material. While it can also provide a stable connection, the shear strength is not as strong as a rivet!
In short, rivets are stronger than screws!
When & Why Use Rivets Instead of Screws？
Under specific structural and process requirements, rivets are more suitable than screws. If your project has special requirements in terms of connection strength, vibration resistance, stability, and limited installation space, then rivets are the ideal solution. The following are typical rivet application scenarios and technical advantages.
Typical application scenarios of Rivets
Single-sided accessible structures
- Such as sheet metal enclosures, sealed chambers, and the interior of extruded profiles—structures where torque cannot be applied from the back. Pop rivets can be quickly installed from the front.
Non-removable connection structures
- Such as aircraft skins, vehicle frames, and building mounting brackets, which require long-term structural stability and cannot loosen due to vibration or accidental operation.
High-vibration or fatigue environments
- Such as rail vehicles, ship hull structures, and industrial machinery, where rivets offer superior resistance to loosening and adaptability to shear loads.
Waterproof sealing requirements
- Such as electrical control enclosures and outdoor equipment housings, where sealed or gasketed rivet connections prevent moisture penetration.
Key advantages of using rivets
- High reliability: Riveting creates a permanent connection that does not rely on thread clamping force and will not loosen due to vibration.
- High adaptability: Suitable for a variety of materials (such as aluminum, stainless steel, and composite materials) and does not require embedded nuts or internal threads.
- High installation efficiency: Can be used with automatic rivet guns to greatly improve assembly efficiency, making it suitable for assembly line work.
- Lighter weight: Compared to large-sized bolts, rivets are more lightweight, making them suitable for applications requiring structural lightweighting.
- Better sealing performance: Through structural design or integrated gaskets, excellent waterproof/airtight performance can be achieved.
Can I Replace Rivets with Screws?
In certain structures, rivets can indeed be replaced with screws, but only under the following key conditions:
- The structure allows for disassembly: Screws are removable fasteners and are only suitable for structures that require maintenance, replacement, or upgrades in the future.
- Hole size compatibility: The original rivet hole diameter must match the target screw or nut system to avoid issues such as poor engagement or loosening.
- Load direction compatibility: If the structure is primarily subjected to tensile loads, screws may be more suitable; however, if the structure is primarily subjected to shear loads, rivets typically offer more reliable performance.
Typical scenarios where replacement is not recommended include:
- High shear or fatigue environments (such as aircraft skins and vehicle body reinforcements)
- Waterproof sealed structures (such as electrical enclosures and outdoor cabinets), where rivets provide stronger sealing
- Single-sided accessible spaces where screws cannot be installed and rivets are required for single-sided operation
If replacement is decided, the following factors should be considered:
- Screw length and thread type: Ensure sufficient clamping force and engagement depth.
- Locking measures: Prevent loosening due to vibration. We recommend using spring washers, nylon lock nuts, or thread sealant.
- Material galvanic corrosion risk: If stainless steel screws are used to connect aluminum plates, corrosion may be exacerbated. We recommend installing insulating washers or selecting compatible metal combinations.
Rivet vs Bolt vs Screw
We often see comparisons such as Rivet vs Bolt vs Screw, and as some of the most commonly used fasteners, they are often compared together. This article introduces you to rivet vs screw.Through this article, you can get a clear understanding of the differences and comparisons between rivets and screws as well as how you should if you are choosing the right fastener for your project.
If you want to know about rivets vs bolts, you can read my other article which explains the difference and usage very well. “https://www.worldrivet.com/rivets-vs-bolts/”
Recommendations for the combined use of screws and rivets
In actual engineering applications, the reasonable combination of screws and rivets can simultaneously ensure structural stability and facilitate post-installation maintenance. This combination is not a compromise but a flexible and efficient structural design strategy. The prerequisite is to clearly distinguish functional zones, control installation quality reasonably, and ensure that each type of fastener performs optimally in its most suitable position.
Recommended scenarios for mixed use:
- Use rivets for main load-bearing structures to ensure secure connections and high fatigue resistance.
- Use screws for non-load-bearing components or maintenance panels to facilitate future disassembly, inspection, or replacement.
- Modular assembly structures, such as electrical control boxes, equipment enclosures, or replaceable components, often adopt this strategy.
Notes and layout recommendations:
- Avoid structural stiffness discontinuities: If screw connections loosen, it may cause localized stress concentration, affecting the overall structural lifespan.
- Maintain consistent installation spacing: Ensure a uniform rhythm in the arrangement of screws and rivets to prevent uneven thermal expansion stress.
- Material compatibility considerations: Select fastener combinations with consistent materials or low risk of galvanic corrosion.
- Clear labeling: It is recommended to mark removable areas or indicate them on drawings to prevent rivet damage due to misoperation.
Buy Pop Rivets in Bulk? Find Rivamte Now!
Are you looking for pop rivet supplier? Don’t worry, we are the top pop rivet manufacturer in China.At Rivamte, you can get all types of pop rivet.
Including standard blind rivets, high-strength structural blind rivets, spr rivets and so on.You can choose from aluminum, stainless steel, and carbon steel!
To find out more, contact our engineers today for a quote!
Reply within 12 Hours
Send us a message if you have any questions or request a quote. We will be back to you ASAP!
Location
+86 189 6230 4392
or write
manufacture@world-rivet.com
